Are Aluminum Doors Better Than Upvc?

When choosing a door material, you have to consider whether you’re building a new home or renovating a commercial space. Doors are not just entry points; they contribute to the overall design, security, energy efficiency, and longevity of a building. 

Aluminum and UPVC (Unplasticized Polyvinyl Chloride) are two of the most popular options in the market, each with its own pros and cons. This article will help you compare aluminum and UPVC doors in detail so you can decide which one is best for you.

Details of Aluminum Doors

Aluminum doors are a light but strong material that is popular in modern architecture. Known for its durability and corrosion resistance, aluminum is used in commercial buildings, high-end homes, and areas with extreme weather. The material’s strength allows for slimmer profiles so you can have a modern look without compromising on structural integrity.

Benefits of Aluminum Doors

• Longevity and Durability: Aluminum is durable and can last for decades with minimal maintenance. Rust and corrosion-resistant, so it is perfect for coastal areas and areas with harsh weather conditions.
• Aesthetic Appeal: Aluminum doors have a modern look that fits contemporary architecture. The material’s strength allows for narrower frames, so you can have larger glass panels and more natural light.
• Energy Efficiency: When combined with thermal breaks, aluminum doors are energy efficient. This helps maintain indoor temperature, reduce energy consumption, and lower utility bills.
• Lightweight Yet Strong: Although light, aluminum is very strong to use. This means you can have larger doors and windows without compromising on security or stability.
• Low Maintenance: Aluminum doors are low maintenance. These doors are easy to clean and have no need for regular painting or varnishing like wooden doors.

Some Drawbacks of Aluminum Doors

• Its Cost: Aluminum is more expensive than UPVC, so it’s a premium option. The higher upfront cost can be a problem for those on a tight budget.
• Corrosion Prone: Although aluminum is rust resistant, it can still corrode in highly saline environments if not treated properly. Special coatings can solve this problem, but they add to the cost.
• Heat Conductor: Aluminum is a good heat conductor, but it can cause energy loss. However, thermal breaks can improve the material’s energy efficiency.

What are UPVC Doors?

These doors are manufactured by unplasticized polyvinyl chloride, a type of plastic that is rigid and strong. UPVC has gained popularity in the door and window industry because of its affordability, durability, and insulation properties. These doors are used in residential buildings, especially in areas with extreme weather conditions, because of their resistance to rot, rust, and fading.

Benefits of UPVC Doors

• Affordability: One of the biggest benefits of UPVC doors is their cost-effectiveness. They are generally cheaper than aluminum doors, so it’s a popular choice for budget-conscious homeowners.
• Insulation Properties: UPVC doors have excellent thermal insulation, so indoor spaces are warm in winter and cool in summer. This can save you energy in the long run.
• Weather Resistance: UPVC is weather resistant to rain, wind, and sunlight. The material does not rot, rust, or corrode, so it’s perfect for areas with extreme climates.
• Low Maintenance: Like aluminum, UPVC doors are low maintenance. Easy to clean and no need for regular painting or varnishing.
• Good Sound Insulation: UPVC doors have good sound insulation, which reduces noise pollution in busy or urban areas.

Some Drawbacks of UPVC Doors

• Durability: Although UPVC doors are durable, they are not as strong as aluminum. They can be more prone to damage, especially in high-traffic areas or commercial settings.
• Limited Design Options: UPVC doors have limited design options compared to aluminum doors. They are available in white or limited color options, which may not suit all design preferences.
• Environmental Concerns: UPVC is a type of plastic that is non-biodegradable. Although it can be recycled, the process is complex, so it’s still a concern. Plus, the production of UPVC uses harmful chemicals.
• Warping and Discoloration: Over time, UPVC doors can warp or discolor, especially in areas with extreme heat or direct sunlight.

Aluminum vs. UPVC Doors

Choosing between aluminum and UPVC doors depends on various criteria like strength, design, and energy efficiency. This is the primary difference between these two typical door options.

Strength and Durability

In strength, aluminum beats UPVC. In hostile environments, aluminum is strong and resistant to severe impact and warping. Commercial areas and high-traffic areas employ aluminum doors for their great usage without revealing any wear and tear. Although UPVC doors will not be used constantly, they are more appropriate for homes where longevity is crucial.

Design and Aesthetic

Design and aesthetics is a major factor for many homeowners and architects. Aluminum doors have a sleek, modern look that can match contemporary architectural design. The material’s strength allows for slimmer frames and larger glass panels, creating a seamless transition between indoor and outdoor spaces.

UPVC doors are functional but less visually appealing. They have a traditional look and limited design options. For those who prioritize aesthetics and design flexibility, aluminum doors are the way to go.

Energy Efficiency

Both aluminum and UPVC doors are energy efficient, but they are achieved in different ways. UPVC has natural insulation properties that help keep indoor spaces comfortable. So, UPVC doors are for extreme weather conditions as they can help reduce energy consumption.

Though it might cause energy loss, aluminum is a decent heat conductor. Modern aluminum doors, however, provide thermal break insulating between the door frame components. Aluminum doors’ energy efficiency is much enhanced by these thermal fractures, which also help them to be insulating equivalent to UPVC.

Environmental Impact

Regarding the effect on the surroundings, both materials offer advantages and drawbacks. Given its great recyclability, aluminum is a more environmentally friendly choice. But aluminum’s energy-intensive manufacturing adds to a larger carbon footprint.

UPVC is more affordable but has environmental concerns because of its plastic composition. It’s non-biodegradable, and while it can be recycled, the process is complex and not always environmentally friendly. The production of UPVC also uses chemicals that can harm the environment.

Cost Comparison

Cost is a major factor when choosing between aluminum and UPVC doors. UPVC doors are generally more affordable upfront, so they are a popular choice for homeowners on a budget. 

Aluminum doors are more expensive initially but can give better value over time because of their durability, low maintenance, and longevity.

When calculating the total cost, you need to include upfront costs along with long-term savings on maintenance, energy efficiency, and replacement. Aluminum doors have high upfront costs, but their long life and low maintenance can make them more cost-effective in the long run.

Why is Aluminum Better for Specific Use Cases?

When deciding between aluminum and UPVC doors, consider their intended usage. Determine which is best for each use situation.

Residential

The requirements and preferences of the homeowner are the primary factors that decide whether aluminum or UPVC doors are suitable for residential use. Due to the fact that they are inexpensive, insulating, and simple to maintain, UPVC doors are becoming increasingly popular in residential settings.

In high-end residential homes, where beauty, durability, and security are of utmost importance, aluminum doors are the material of choice. Due to its streamlined appearance and contemporary design, it is a well-liked option for contemporary houses. In addition, aluminum doors are ideal for wider openings, since their strength enables them to accommodate larger glass panels.

Commercial

In commercial use, aluminum doors are the preferred choice because of their strength, durability, and modern design. Commercial buildings need doors that can withstand heavy use and a high level of security, and aluminum doors excel in those areas. Its low maintenance requirement makes it perfect for commercial properties.

UPVC doors can also be used for commercial use, especially in smaller offices or low-budget projects. However, it may not have the same level of durability or aesthetic appeal as aluminum doors, so it’s not suitable for high-traffic areas or large commercial buildings.

Climate

Aluminum nut doors are durable and have some detailed requirements, like special coating to protect against corrosion in coastal areas or high-humidity regions. With the right treatment, aluminum can perform well in any climate. Also, the use of thermal breaks in aluminum doors can improve its energy efficiency in hot and cold climates.

Conclusion

It all depends on your demands, interests, and money. Both materials have pros and cons, making them suited for diverse applications. Aluminum and UPVC doors are good options, depending on your needs. 

But if you’re looking for a long-term investment with a modern look, aluminum doors are the best value for your money. For premium aluminum doors, look no further than Guangzhou APRO Building Material Co. Ltd. 

Guangzhou APRO Building Material makes a variety of bespoke aluminum doors for home and commercial usage, known for their quality. Modern design, great durability, and enhanced energy efficiency make these doors ideal for any project. Contact them immediately!